Many things that used to be done in the home by hand are now being done by machines. Does this development bring more advantages or disadvantages?

Same question Compare 2 different answers (Band 8)

Sample Response

The integration of machines into household chores has significantly altered the way domestic tasks are accomplished. While some may argue that this transition poses disadvantages, the advantages of leveraging machines for household activities undoubtedly outweigh the drawbacks.

The proliferation of machines in home tasks brings certain disadvantages. One significant concern is the potential loss of certain practical skills and the disconnect from the tactile experience of performing chores manually. For instance, the reliance on automated cooking appliances might hinder individuals, especially younger generations, from learning traditional culinary skills passed down through generations. The art of kneading the dough by hand or mastering the precise seasoning of a dish may diminish with the prevalent use of automated kitchen gadgets, impacting the appreciation and mastery of culinary arts.

On the other hand, one of the most compelling advantages of automation is the liberation from mundane and time-consuming tasks. Machines can handle chores like laundry, cleaning, and cooking with remarkable efficiency, freeing up valuable time for individuals to pursue personal interests, spend time with loved ones, or simply relax and recharge. This improved quality of life is particularly beneficial for working professionals and families with busy schedules. Furthermore, automation enhances task precision and consistency. Machines are capable of performing repetitive tasks with accuracy, reducing errors that may occur with manual execution. For instance, dishwashers ensure thorough and hygienic cleaning consistently, which might not always be achieved through handwashing.

In conclusion, the incorporation of machines into household tasks has ushered in a myriad of advantages, ranging from time-saving benefits and improved precision to resource efficiency and enhanced quality of life. Embracing automation in the home is pivotal for fostering convenience, productivity, and sustainability in modern living.

IELTS Writing Correction

  • 1. Use precise collocation Original: integration of machines into household chores Suggested revision: use of machines for household chores Why it matters: Machines are used for chores rather than integrated into the chores themselves.
  • 2. Avoid business jargon Original: leveraging Suggested revision: using Why it matters: Using is clearer and more natural than the business-oriented verb leveraging here.
  • 3. Clarify the phrase Original: proliferation of machines in home tasks Suggested revision: increased use of machines for household tasks Why it matters: This wording describes the trend directly and uses the correct relationship between machines and tasks.
  • 4. Specify the skills Original: potential loss of certain practical skills Suggested revision: potential loss of practical household skills Why it matters: Household identifies the relevant type of practical skill more precisely than certain.
  • 5. Use direct wording Original: the disconnect from the tactile experience Suggested revision: a loss of direct experience Why it matters: This concise phrase states the intended disadvantage without an abstract nominal construction.
  • 6. Moderate the wording Original: liberation Suggested revision: relief Why it matters: Relief is a more natural and proportionate noun for avoiding household chores.
  • 7. Clarify the relationship Original: task precision and consistency Suggested revision: precision and consistency in household tasks Why it matters: The revised phrase states clearly where the precision and consistency occur.
  • 8. Write more concisely Original: are capable of performing Suggested revision: can perform Why it matters: The shorter modal construction conveys the same meaning without unnecessary wording.
  • 9. Use natural phrasing Original: through handwashing Suggested revision: by hand Why it matters: By hand is the conventional concise contrast with machine washing.
  • 10. Avoid inflated wording Original: a myriad of advantages Suggested revision: numerous advantages Why it matters: Numerous is a direct academic alternative that avoids an inflated expression.
  • 11. Sentence rewrite Original: The art of kneading the dough by hand or mastering the precise seasoning of a dish may diminish with the prevalent use of automated kitchen gadgets, impacting the appreciation and mastery of culinary arts. Suggested revision: The skills of kneading dough by hand and seasoning a dish precisely may decline as automated kitchen gadgets become more common, reducing people's appreciation and mastery of culinary arts. Why it matters: The rewrite creates parallel noun phrases and gives the final participial clause a clear logical subject.

Suggested Rewrites

  • integration of machines into household chores use of machines for household chores
  • leveraging using
  • proliferation of machines in home tasks increased use of machines for household tasks
  • potential loss of certain practical skills potential loss of practical household skills
  • the disconnect from the tactile experience a loss of direct experience
  • liberation relief
Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 8.0

The response gives a clear comparative judgement and develops both disadvantages and advantages with focused explanations and concrete household examples. Its main limitation is that the conclusion introduces resource efficiency and sustainability without developing them in the essay, slightly weakening the precision of the final synthesis. The highest-priority improvement is to ensure every concluding claim directly reflects an idea established in the body paragraphs.

Band score breakdown

IELTS Writing Criteria Scores

TR

Task Response

8.0
Scoring rule

The question is fully addressed through a clear position and well-supported comparison of drawbacks and stronger benefits.

Next step

Remove or develop the new claims about resource efficiency and sustainability that appear only in the conclusion.

CC

Coherence and Cohesion

8.0
Scoring rule

Information is sequenced logically, and cohesive devices guide the reader clearly through the contrasting sides and supporting examples.

Next step

Keep the conclusion tightly aligned with the body so the final progression feels completely unified.

LR

Lexical Resource

8.0
Scoring rule

Vocabulary is wide, precise, and appropriately academic, with effective topic-specific language used throughout.

Next step

Refine the few less natural combinations, such as 'prevalent use', to make the lexical control consistently idiomatic.

GRA

Grammatical Range and Accuracy

8.0
Scoring rule

A wide variety of complex sentence forms is handled accurately, with punctuation and agreement consistently controlled.

Next step

Continue refining long sentences so their subordinate details remain as concise as the simpler statements.

Put the feedback to work

Write this task while it is fresh

Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.

IELTS Writing Task 2

Many things that used to be done in the home by hand are now being done by machines. Does this development bring more advantages or disadvantages?

Your response

Words0
40:00

Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.