Due to the effects of globalisation, the cultures of some countries are influenced by others. Some people think this is a natural process. Others think this is a threat to cultural identity. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
Sample Response
Globalization has undeniably fostered interconnectedness among countries, leading to the exchange of ideas, values, and cultural elements. While some perceive this as a natural and enriching process, others argue that it poses a significant threat to cultural identity. In this essay, I will delve into both perspectives and explain why I believe that the influence of one culture on another can indeed jeopardize the unique identity of nations.
On the one hand, proponents of cultural globalization argue that it is a natural consequence of increased communication and global interaction. They contend that exposure to different customs and traditions enhances cultural diversity, fostering a more inclusive and tolerant global society. For example, the widespread popularity of international cuisines in various countries demonstrates the positive aspects of cultural exchange, creating a melting pot of culinary diversity.
On the other hand, there is a growing concern that the influence of dominant cultures can overshadow and erode the distinctive features of smaller or less influential nations. This is particularly evident in the prevalence of Western ideals in media, fashion, and lifestyle choices, often at the expense of indigenous traditions. For instance, the global dominance of Hollywood movies and Western fashion trends can lead to the marginalization of local film industries and traditional clothing styles.
Personally, I align with the viewpoint that globalization poses a threat to cultural identity. While cultural exchange can be enriching, the imbalance in influence can lead to cultural homogenization, where unique traditions risk fading into obscurity.
In conclusion, the effects of globalization on cultural exchange evoke contrasting opinions. While some see it as a natural and positive evolution, others raise valid concerns about its potential threat to cultural identity. However, it is evident that it often threatens the local traditions and even erodes the cultural identity of a nation.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Use direct wording Original: fostered interconnectedness among countries Suggested revision: increased interconnectedness between countries Why it matters: The revision expresses the relationship more directly and naturally.
- 2. Choose a concrete noun Original: cultural elements Suggested revision: cultural practices Why it matters: Practices is more specific than the broad noun elements in this context.
- 3. Clarify the reference Original: some perceive this Suggested revision: some view this exchange Why it matters: Naming the exchange makes the pronoun reference immediately clear.
- 4. Use concise wording Original: delve into Suggested revision: examine Why it matters: Examine is a more concise academic verb for introducing the discussion.
- 5. Remove excess emphasis Original: indeed jeopardize Suggested revision: jeopardize Why it matters: The claim is already explicit, so the intensifier adds little precision.
- 6. Simplify the label Original: proponents of cultural globalization Suggested revision: supporters of cultural globalization Why it matters: The simpler label remains formal and is easier to read.
- 7. Be more specific Original: global interaction Suggested revision: cross-border interaction Why it matters: This wording identifies the international nature of the interaction more precisely.
- 8. Refine the collocation Original: enhances cultural diversity Suggested revision: broadens cultural diversity Why it matters: Broadens better conveys an increase in the range of cultural influences.
- 9. Reduce wordiness Original: in various countries Suggested revision: worldwide Why it matters: The single adverb conveys the same broad geographical meaning more efficiently.
- 10. Use a precise noun Original: positive aspects Suggested revision: benefits Why it matters: Benefits states the intended positive effect more directly.
- 11. Link example to claim Suggested revision: After the cuisine example, add a brief link back to the paragraph's claim about tolerance and inclusion. Why it matters: The paragraph currently ends on culinary variety without reconnecting it to its broader point.
- 12. Strengthen example transition Suggested revision: Signal explicitly that the Hollywood and fashion examples illustrate the preceding claim about Western influence. Why it matters: A clearer bridge would make the movement from the general claim to the examples more explicit.
Suggested Rewrites
- fostered interconnectedness among countries increased interconnectedness between countries
- cultural elements cultural practices
- some perceive this some view this exchange
- delve into examine
- indeed jeopardize jeopardize
- proponents of cultural globalization supporters of cultural globalization
Why this response received Band 8.0
The essay offers a clear, well-organised discussion of both perspectives and sustains a definite opinion with relevant examples. Its main limitation is that some reasoning remains broad and familiar, particularly the benefits of cultural exchange, while the conclusion repeats earlier claims. The strongest improvement would be to develop the causal analysis more deeply and qualify how unequal cultural influence produces the stated consequences.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Detailed feedback by IELTS writing criterion after the annotated essay.
Task Response
Both views are directly addressed, the opinion is clear throughout, and each main idea is supported with a relevant example.
Deepen the analysis by explaining more precisely when cultural exchange becomes enrichment and when unequal influence becomes erosion.
Coherence and Cohesion
The response progresses logically through a clear introduction, contrasting body paragraphs, a personal position, and a conclusion.
Make the final paragraph more selective so it synthesises the argument instead of largely restating earlier positions.
Lexical Resource
Vocabulary is wide, precise, and appropriately academic, with effective terms such as ‘cultural homogenization’ and ‘marginalization’.
Refine a few conventional or slightly awkward phrases, such as ‘evoke contrasting opinions’ and ‘threatens the local traditions’, for greater naturalness.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A wide range of complex structures is used accurately, and the few minor imperfections do not impede communication.
For further refinement, vary sentence openings and reduce reliance on introductory participial phrases while preserving the current accuracy.
Use this task for your next draft
Feedback is more useful when you actively apply it in a draft, rather than only recognising improvements on the page.
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.
The question will be loaded automatically.