Some people think that managers alone should make decisions in the company, while others think that employees should be involved in the decision-making process too. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
Sample Response
There are strong arguments that the authority of the company must plan their actions towards the success of their business. However, some individuals are convinced that employees must participate in the strategy of a company. Primarily, it is often said that the authority of the company is the one who invested most of the fund in their company. Some of the chief executive officers have started from small scale business industries before they reach the highest success of their companies. In other words, they have a number of managerial experiences which they could apply to proliferate their income. Hence, they do not need the advice of the employees as they might have different skills on other fields, which are not suitable for deciding better actions in a company. For instance, a computer programmer who works in a private institution may not contribute to the decisions about financial management. Furthermore, the fundamental purpose of business owners is to recover their recover the capital they invested in their companies. To illustrate, in a supermarket, most goods being sold are important because the earnings will be used to supplement the products, which sustain the continuity of a business. However, it can never be denied that the employees are part of a company. It is their privilege to contribute to the success of a company due to the fact that they will benefit from its monetary gain. As an instance, the employer might increase their salary because they made the greatest contribution to the improvement of business. Hence, their collaboration will bring favourable benefits to them, which may strengthen the teamwork and collaboration. Moreover, it is apparent that more ideas are imperative to the management of a business. It is possible that the owner of the company could commit erroneous decisions, which may be corrected by some workers such as staffing and scheduling in an institution. To conclude, I personally believe that employees must partake to the plans of a company as the authority might sometimes create irrational actions. It is very likely that if the employer and the worker merge their ideas, they will receive a propitious success.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Use natural term Original: the authority of the company must Suggested revision: company management must Why it matters: 'Company management' is the natural term for those who direct a business.
- 2. Clarify the purpose Original: plan their actions towards the success Suggested revision: plan their actions to ensure the success Why it matters: The revised phrase states the intended purpose with a natural collocation.
- 3. Use precise collocation Original: participate in the strategy Suggested revision: participate in strategic planning Why it matters: People participate in strategic planning rather than in a strategy itself.
- 4. Clarify the subject Original: the authority of the company is the one Suggested revision: company management comprises those Why it matters: The revision avoids treating a collective group as a single vague person.
- 5. Use plural noun Original: fund Suggested revision: funds Why it matters: The plural 'funds' means the money invested in a company.
- 6. Correct the tense Original: before they reach Suggested revision: before reaching Why it matters: The gerund creates a grammatical sequence after 'have started'.
- 7. Improve the collocation Original: highest Suggested revision: greatest Why it matters: 'Greatest success' is the natural collocation for a high level of achievement.
- 8. Use uncountable experience Original: a number of managerial experiences Suggested revision: considerable managerial experience Why it matters: 'Experience' is uncountable when it means accumulated professional knowledge.
- 9. Use natural wording Original: apply to proliferate their income Suggested revision: use to increase their companies' income Why it matters: 'Use to increase' expresses the intended business outcome more naturally.
- 10. Correct the preposition Original: on Suggested revision: in Why it matters: The correct preposition with fields of expertise is 'in'.
- 11. Use standard collocation Original: deciding better actions Suggested revision: making better decisions Why it matters: English uses the collocation 'make decisions' rather than 'decide actions'.
- 12. Use concise possessive Original: the advice of the employees Suggested revision: employees' advice Why it matters: The possessive form makes the noun phrase more concise and natural.
Suggested Rewrites
- the authority of the company must company management must
- plan their actions towards the success plan their actions to ensure the success
- participate in the strategy participate in strategic planning
- the authority of the company is the one company management comprises those
- fund funds
- before they reach before reaching
Why this response received Band 6.0
The response discusses both decision-making models and gives a clear preference for employee participation, with useful points about managerial expertise and workers correcting staffing or scheduling mistakes. Its main limitation is uneven development: the supermarket example does not clearly support manager-only decisions, and the single-paragraph format obscures the argument. Prioritise organising the two views into focused body paragraphs with precise, directly relevant examples.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
Both views and the writer’s opinion are addressed, but support is uneven and the supermarket example has an unclear connection to managerial authority.
Give each view one directly relevant example and explain how it demonstrates the advantages or limits of that decision-making model.
Coherence and Cohesion
The ideas follow a broadly logical sequence, but presenting the entire response as one paragraph weakens organisation and makes transitions feel mechanical.
Separate the introduction, each view, and the conclusion into distinct paragraphs with one controlling idea in each body paragraph.
Lexical Resource
The response attempts a reasonably wide vocabulary, but frequent inaccurate collocations and word choices reduce precision and naturalness.
Prefer accurate phrases such as ‘senior management’, ‘make poor decisions’, ‘contribute to company plans’, and ‘achieve greater success’.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A mix of simple and complex structures conveys the main meaning, although agreement, tense, article, pronoun, and preposition errors recur.
Use shorter controlled sentences while checking subject-verb agreement and the verb patterns that follow common business expressions.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people think that managers alone should make decisions in the company, while others think that employees should be involved in the decision-making process too. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.