Nowadays some older people choose to live in retirement communities and centers with other people, rather than living with their adult children. Is this a positive or negative development?
Sample Response
It is becoming increasingly common for senior citizens to retire to assisted care facilities instead of remaining at home with their children. In my opinion, though these institutions often have a reputation for abuse, it is a positive trend as it liberates younger generations.
Detractors of such communities highlight notable instances of abuse. These are detailed in frequent, highly publicized, exposes from reputable news organizations on a regular basis. Many of these incidents become criminal or civil cases and the instances of mistreatment are memorably cruel. Elderly people have been known to be beaten, demeaned and neglected in terms of their basic sanitary needs. These vulnerable individuals often lack the ability to defend themselves or voice the abuse to visiting family. However, considering the total number of seniors in assisted care facilities, abuse is rare and likely to decrease in the future as technology allows for closer monitoring of employees.
Overall, I believe retirement communities to be a positive as they are liberating for families. This applies to the seniors themselves as, though they may be restricted from leaving the premises, they can interact with their peers and form meaningful, new bonds. The greatest benefits, however, are for the family unit as a whole. Families are rarely equipped with the medical training or financial resources to support aging individuals. For instance, it is a nearly impossible task for a family where both mother and father work to look after an ailing parent as well as their own young children. They are likely to lack some combination of energy, will, means, and time. By placing their parents in an elderly home, they will have more time to invest in raising their own children and advancing at work, which will itself increase the standard of living for all family members.
In conclusion, the risk of possible abuse at retirement homes does not overshadow the benefits generally for families. This is a sensitive topic but each individual must decide what is in their own best interests.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Use natural verb phrase Original: retire to assisted care facilities Suggested revision: move into assisted care facilities Why it matters: People normally move into a care facility rather than retire to one.
- 2. Correct the collocation Original: incidents become criminal or civil cases Suggested revision: incidents lead to criminal or civil cases Why it matters: Incidents lead to legal cases; they do not themselves become cases.
- 3. Choose precise intensity Original: memorably Suggested revision: exceptionally Why it matters: Exceptionally describes the degree of cruelty more precisely than memorably.
- 4. Use report abuse Original: voice the abuse to visiting family Suggested revision: report the abuse to visiting family members Why it matters: Report is the natural verb for telling others about abuse.
- 5. Clarify the comparison Original: considering the total number of seniors in assisted care facilities Suggested revision: relative to the total number of seniors in assisted care facilities Why it matters: Relative to makes the numerical comparison underlying the claim explicit.
- 6. Complete the noun phrase Original: retirement communities to be a positive Suggested revision: retirement communities to be a positive development Why it matters: Positive needs a noun here to complete the complement.
- 7. Remove adjective comma Original: meaningful, new bonds Suggested revision: meaningful new bonds Why it matters: A comma is not needed between these cumulative adjectives.
- 8. Use precise relative form Original: where both mother and father work Suggested revision: in which both parents work Why it matters: In which correctly refers to the family situation and both parents is more concise.
- 9. Use standard term Original: an elderly home Suggested revision: a care home Why it matters: Care home is the standard term for a residential facility for older people.
- 10. Sentence rewrite Original: These are detailed in frequent, highly publicized, exposes from reputable news organizations on a regular basis. Suggested revision: These cases are detailed regularly in highly publicized exposés by reputable news organizations. Why it matters: This removes repetition, fixes the erroneous comma, and uses a more precise subject.
- 11. Sequence the two benefits Suggested revision: Signal the shift from benefits for seniors to the larger benefits for the family unit more explicitly. Why it matters: Clearer sequencing would make the paragraph's two-part progression easier to follow.
Suggested Rewrites
- retire to assisted care facilities move into assisted care facilities
- incidents become criminal or civil cases incidents lead to criminal or civil cases
- memorably exceptionally
- voice the abuse to visiting family report the abuse to visiting family members
- considering the total number of seniors in assisted care facilities relative to the total number of seniors in assisted care facilities
- retirement communities to be a positive retirement communities to be a positive development
Why this response received Band 8.0
The response presents a clear, consistently maintained position and develops both the acknowledged risk of abuse and the broader benefits to families with relevant explanation. Its main limitation is that a few claims are somewhat sweeping and the final sentence slightly dilutes the otherwise firm judgement; prioritise qualifying those claims and ending with a sharper restatement of why the development is positive.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
The question is fully addressed through a clear positive judgement, a considered counterargument, and well-developed benefits for seniors and their families.
Qualify broad claims about the rarity and future decline of abuse, and keep the final judgement fully aligned with the established position.
Coherence and Cohesion
Ideas progress logically through a clear introduction, counterargument, positive case, and conclusion, with cohesive devices used effectively.
Use a more precise transition than “Overall” to introduce the main supporting paragraph and sharpen the connection between its two beneficiary groups.
Lexical Resource
A wide and precise vocabulary supports nuanced discussion, with only occasional awkward choices such as “memorably cruel” and “voice the abuse.”
Refine the few unnatural collocations so that sophisticated vocabulary remains consistently idiomatic.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A broad range of complex structures is handled accurately, and the few minor slips do not impede communication.
Polish article use and sentence phrasing in the small number of awkward constructions to achieve more consistently effortless control.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Nowadays some older people choose to live in retirement communities and centers with other people, rather than living with their adult children. Is this a positive or negative development?
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.