Some people say that the best way to teach children to cooperate is through team sports at school. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Sample Response
Some people believe that team sports in schools are the most effective method for teaching children cooperation. Personally, I disagree with this notion as I believe that although sports can contribute to teamwork skills, other educational and social activities provide a more comprehensive and inclusive approach to fostering cooperation.
One key reason why team sports are not the best way to teach cooperation is that they primarily focus on physical ability and competition. Many children may not enjoy or excel in sports, leading to frustration or exclusion rather than fostering genuine teamwork. Moreover, competitive environments in sports often emphasize winning over cooperation, which can sometimes encourage aggressive behaviour rather than collaborative problem-solving. For example, in high-stakes school competitions, some students prioritize individual performance over teamwork, undermining the very cooperation that sports are meant to teach. A more effective approach to instilling cooperation is engaging students in group-based academic projects and extracurricular activities such as drama, debate clubs, or community service initiatives. These activities require constant communication, mutual understanding, and shared responsibility, which are fundamental to cooperative behaviour.
Furthermore, cooperation is best developed in real-world social interactions where children learn to resolve conflicts, share responsibilities, and support one another outside the framework of competition. Activities such as peer mentoring programs or volunteering encourage students to collaborate with diverse individuals, promoting inclusivity and empathy. Unlike sports, which often group children based on ability, these initiatives provide an equal platform for all students to develop cooperative skills.
In conclusion, while team sports can contribute to teaching cooperation, they are not the best approach. Alternative methods such as collaborative academic projects, extracurricular activities, and social initiatives offer a more inclusive and effective way to develop teamwork and cooperation among children.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Use infinitive complement Original: teaching children cooperation Suggested revision: teaching children to cooperate Why it matters: The verb “teach” takes an object followed by an infinitive in this meaning.
- 2. Use concise approach phrase Original: provide a more comprehensive and inclusive approach to fostering cooperation Suggested revision: offer more comprehensive and inclusive ways to foster cooperation Why it matters: The revision keeps the meaning while reducing abstract nominal wording.
- 3. Clarify sporting emphasis Original: ability Suggested revision: performance Why it matters: “Physical performance” more precisely describes what competitive sports emphasize.
- 4. Vary repeated verb Original: fostering Suggested revision: developing Why it matters: “Developing” avoids repeating “fostering” while preserving the intended meaning.
- 5. Use precise priority verb Original: emphasize Suggested revision: prioritize Why it matters: “Prioritize” expresses the contrast between the two aims more directly.
- 6. Use parallel infinitive structure Original: A more effective approach to instilling cooperation is engaging Suggested revision: A more effective way to instill cooperation is to engage Why it matters: Parallel infinitives make the definition clearer and more natural.
- 7. Use measured frequency term Original: constant Suggested revision: sustained Why it matters: “Sustained” conveys ongoing communication without the absolute implication of “constant.”
- 8. Make setting phrase concise Original: outside the framework of competition Suggested revision: outside competitive settings Why it matters: The shorter phrase conveys the same distinction more directly.
- 9. Keep British spelling consistent Original: programs Suggested revision: programmes Why it matters: British spelling is more consistent with the essay’s use of “behaviour.”
- 10. Remove overlapping terms Original: teamwork and cooperation among children Suggested revision: cooperation among children Why it matters: “Teamwork” and “cooperation” overlap here, so one term is sufficient.
Suggested Rewrites
- teaching children cooperation teaching children to cooperate
- provide a more comprehensive and inclusive approach to fostering cooperation offer more comprehensive and inclusive ways to foster cooperation
- ability performance
- fostering developing
- emphasize prioritize
- A more effective approach to instilling cooperation is engaging A more effective way to instill cooperation is to engage
Why this response received Band 8.5
The essay directly challenges the superlative claim, acknowledges the value of sports, and develops a persuasive case for more inclusive alternatives through competition, exclusion, academic projects, mentoring, volunteering, empathy, and conflict resolution. Organisation and language are consistently strong; the main refinement is to support the alternative activities with one concrete observed outcome rather than relying mainly on plausible general explanation.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
The position is precise and fully developed, with relevant analysis of sports' limitations and well-explained educational and social alternatives.
As a refinement, add one specific example showing how a collaborative project or mentoring activity measurably improved children's cooperation.
Coherence and Cohesion
The introduction, two focused body paragraphs, and conclusion form a clear progression, with ideas linked naturally within and across paragraphs.
Consider separating the long first body paragraph after the critique of competitive sport so the alternative methods receive slightly more structural emphasis.
Lexical Resource
A wide and precise range conveys competition, exclusion, problem-solving, shared responsibility, inclusivity, empathy, and cooperative behaviour naturally.
Maintain this precision while varying repeated forms of "cooperation" with exact alternatives such as "collaboration" or "teamwork" where appropriate.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
Complex sentences are varied, accurate, and fluently controlled, with strong punctuation and only negligible lapses.
For maximum concision, shorten a few sentences containing multiple coordinated examples without reducing their analytical force.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people say that the best way to teach children to cooperate is through team sports at school. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.