People who have original ideas are of much greater value to society than those who are simply able to copy the ideas of others well. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
Sample Response
People who have original ideas are of much greater value to society than those who are simply able to copy the idea of others well. Agree or disagree? In the history of humankind, people have been attempting to facilitate numerous leaps and bounds in their life by sharing their idea to each other. In this regard, societies highly appreciate those who provide their original opinions while those who emulate others idea considered less valuable. From my point of view, this is open to debate. The first justification that supports those copying others instructions is that they realised any pros and cons of the dilemma that might occur and the outcome is almost obvious for all. In addition, it is noteworthy that people prefer to put forward those opinions which have tested several times. Taking teachers as an example, they have an inclination to mimic the skills that precedence ones applied in the educational system to transfer knowledge to students, so it is unfair if we underestimate their efforts. Despite those points mentioned above in favour of emulators, an overt advantage of having creative people in a society is novel solutions for some problems which will appear. An innovative person is admirable in each country due to the fact that he/she has a power of thinking quickly and making an appropriate decision. Furthermore, these people are considered as intelligent and bear dynamism either in the work ambience and their family. Therefore, on the ground of these positive elements, they are much more admirable. To summarise, although emulating others idea is considered boring and under value, we should not overlook the side of the fact that it has several valuable experiences behind itself. However, I believe that innovative people are much more worthwhile.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Fix mixed collocation Original: facilitate numerous leaps and bounds Suggested revision: make substantial advances Why it matters: “Facilitate leaps and bounds” is not a natural collocation for describing human progress.
- 2. Use the plural noun Original: life Suggested revision: lives Why it matters: The plural possessive “their” requires the plural noun “lives” in this general statement.
- 3. Fix number and preposition Original: sharing their idea to each other Suggested revision: sharing their ideas with one another Why it matters: The plural “ideas” and the preposition “with” are required in this construction.
- 4. Use accurate wording Original: provide their original opinions Suggested revision: contribute original ideas Why it matters: “Contribute ideas” is the natural expression and matches the topic more accurately than “provide opinions.”
- 5. Add possession and verb Original: emulate others idea considered Suggested revision: emulate others' ideas are considered Why it matters: The noun needs a possessive apostrophe and the passive clause needs the auxiliary “are.”
- 6. Fix clause and possession Original: supports those copying others instructions Suggested revision: supports those who copy others' instructions Why it matters: A relative clause and possessive apostrophe make the phrase grammatical.
- 7. Use consistent tense Original: realised Suggested revision: realise Why it matters: The present tense is needed because the sentence makes a general claim.
- 8. Use the definite article Original: any Suggested revision: the Why it matters: The definite article is appropriate when referring to the identifiable advantages and disadvantages of a choice.
- 9. Fix the collocation Original: dilemma that might occur Suggested revision: situation that might arise Why it matters: A situation can arise, whereas a dilemma does not naturally “occur” in this context.
- 10. Clarify the outcome Original: almost obvious for all Suggested revision: largely predictable to everyone Why it matters: This wording clearly conveys that the likely result is known in advance.
- 11. Add the passive form Original: opinions which have tested several times Suggested revision: ideas that have been tested several times Why it matters: The passive auxiliary “been” is required because the ideas receive the testing.
- 12. Use concise wording Original: have an inclination to mimic Suggested revision: tend to imitate Why it matters: The revision conveys the same meaning more concisely and naturally.
Suggested Rewrites
- facilitate numerous leaps and bounds make substantial advances
- life lives
- sharing their idea to each other sharing their ideas with one another
- provide their original opinions contribute original ideas
- emulate others idea considered emulate others' ideas are considered
- supports those copying others instructions supports those who copy others' instructions
Why this response received Band 6.0
The response’s strongest feature is its attempt to consider the value of both imitation and originality before reaching a clear final preference for innovators. Its main limitation is that several arguments are expressed vaguely and the single-block presentation weakens the progression. The highest-priority improvement is to organise the two sides into distinct paragraphs and explain each claim in accurate, direct language with a specific supporting example.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
The response addresses the issue and gives a final position, but the initial stance is vague and several supporting ideas are insufficiently explained.
State the degree of agreement clearly in the introduction and develop why innovators create greater social value with a concrete example.
Coherence and Cohesion
The sequence from imitation to innovation and conclusion is discernible, but the absence of paragraphs and mechanical linking reduce clarity.
Separate the introduction, each side of the argument, and the conclusion into purposeful paragraphs with clear topic sentences.
Lexical Resource
There is an adequate range of vocabulary and some less common items, but frequent inaccurate collocations and word choices reduce precision.
Replace expressions such as precedence ones, bear dynamism, and under value with natural, context-appropriate wording.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
The response uses both simple and complex forms, though recurring agreement, possessive, article, and passive-form errors are noticeable.
Prioritise plural and possessive accuracy and check that passive clauses include the required form of be.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
People who have original ideas are of much greater value to society than those who are simply able to copy the ideas of others well. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.