Some people think that cities are the best places to live. Others prefer to live in a rural area. Compare the advantages and disadvantages of living in the city to living in the countryside.
Sample Response
Radically different causes motivate whether an individual prefers and lives in an urban area or a rural area. This essay will compare the benefits and drawbacks of residing in the city to residing in a rural area.
Cities are vibrant centres of opportunity and services. They boast modern amenities, such as state-of-the-art medical care, academic institutions, and public transportation. Employment prospects are highly diverse, offering a wide array of career paths and handsome salaries in many cases. The fast-paced environment of cities appeals to those high-achieving millennials seeking challenging and dynamic workplaces. However, this has its drawbacks like higher cost of living, traffic congestion, and environmental pollution.
In contrast, rural life offers a peaceful and tight-knit community environment, removed from noise, pollution, and hectic city life. The slower-paced life allows residents to form a deeper connection both with nature and people. Villagers can take a deep breath of fresh air, and enjoy the tranquillity of vast green space. Small rural communities foster a stronger sense of solidarity. Neighborly relations are frequent, contributing to emotional well-being. Countryside, however, may lack the services and conveniences readily available in urban areas, including specialized healthcare, educational institutions, and job opportunities.
Social fabric differs significantly between the two settings. Cities foster individuality and anonymity, promoting diverse social interactions but often provoking a sense of alienation. Countryside, on the contrary, places emphasis on mutual support and collective interests, offering an intimate social atmosphere where everyone knows each other.
In conclusion, while cities promise convenience and opportunity, countrysides offer serenity and a deeper sense of social solidarity. However, the preference between city life and rural life depends on individual preferences and priorities.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Use a natural collocation Original: Radically different causes motivate whether Suggested revision: Various factors influence whether Why it matters: Factors influence a preference, whereas causes do not naturally motivate whether someone chooses a location.
- 2. Correct the verb pattern Original: prefers and lives Suggested revision: prefers to live Why it matters: Prefer is followed by an infinitive when describing the location someone chooses.
- 3. Clarify the comparison Original: benefits and drawbacks of residing in the city to residing in a rural area Suggested revision: benefits and drawbacks of residing in a city with those of residing in a rural area Why it matters: The parallel comparison makes clear that the two sets of benefits and drawbacks are being contrasted.
- 4. Name the referent Original: this has its drawbacks Suggested revision: urban living has its drawbacks Why it matters: This has an unclear referent after a sentence about both cities and people.
- 5. Introduce examples formally Original: like higher cost of living Suggested revision: such as a higher cost of living Why it matters: Such as is more precise for introducing examples, and cost needs an article here.
- 6. Place both correctly Original: both with nature and people Suggested revision: with both nature and other people Why it matters: Both should directly precede the two coordinated nouns.
- 7. Remove the unnecessary comma Original: air, and Suggested revision: air and Why it matters: No comma is needed between two predicates sharing the same subject.
- 8. Use the plural noun Original: vast green space Suggested revision: vast green spaces Why it matters: The plural form naturally refers to multiple expanses of rural land.
- 9. Use a natural collocation Original: Neighborly relations are frequent Suggested revision: Neighbourly interactions are common Why it matters: Interactions can be frequent or common, while relations are not naturally described as frequent here.
- 10. Add the definite article Original: Countryside, however Suggested revision: The countryside, however Why it matters: Countryside normally requires the definite article when used as a general setting.
- 11. Use the contrast marker Original: Countryside, on the contrary Suggested revision: The countryside, by contrast Why it matters: By contrast is the appropriate linker for comparing two settings, and countryside needs an article.
- 12. Use the uncountable form Original: countrysides offer Suggested revision: the countryside offers Why it matters: Countryside is used as a singular general concept here, so it takes the article and singular verb.
Suggested Rewrites
- Radically different causes motivate whether Various factors influence whether
- prefers and lives prefers to live
- benefits and drawbacks of residing in the city to residing in a rural area benefits and drawbacks of residing in a city with those of residing in a rural area
- this has its drawbacks urban living has its drawbacks
- like higher cost of living such as a higher cost of living
- both with nature and people with both nature and other people
Why this response received Band 7.5
The response presents a clear, well-organized comparison, with particularly effective coverage of services, employment, environment, and social relationships in both settings. Its main limitation is that several points are asserted or listed rather than explored through specific consequences or examples, while a few awkward collocations slightly weaken precision. The best improvement would be to deepen one or two central comparisons instead of adding further advantages and disadvantages.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Detailed feedback by IELTS writing criterion after the annotated essay.
Task Response
Both settings are compared directly through a broad and relevant range of advantages and disadvantages, though some points remain briefly developed.
Extend the most important comparisons with a specific consequence or example rather than relying on lists.
Coherence and Cohesion
Ideas progress logically through well-focused paragraphs, and cohesive devices guide the comparison smoothly.
Refine the link between the social-fabric paragraph and the preceding comparison to make the progression even tighter.
Lexical Resource
Vocabulary is varied and generally precise, with strong topic-specific phrasing despite occasional awkward or overstated collocations.
Use more natural combinations for phrases such as radically different causes and handsome salaries.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A wide range of complex structures is handled accurately, with only occasional article, punctuation, and noun-form slips.
Proofread article use with countryside and remove unnecessary commas in compound predicates.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people think that cities are the best places to live. Others prefer to live in a rural area. Compare the advantages and disadvantages of living in the city to living in the countryside.
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.