In modern society, it is no longer necessary to slaughter animals for producing foodstuffs, or non-food products such as clothes or medicine. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Same questionCompare 2 different answers (Band 8)

Sample Response

1

In an era of growing public concern over animal conservation, whether animals should be killed to produce food, clothing, and medicinefood, clothing and medicine has sparked significantfierce debate. From my perspective, slaughtering animals for human needs can be justified, though this practice must be subject to strict regulation. Admittedly, animal-sourced products bring tangible benefits to human health and nutritionhuman welfare. Meat, for example, contains high levels of protein, an essential nutrient for muscle and bone development. Without adequate protein from livestock, people may become more vulnerablepeople become more vulnerable to a range of health conditions. Strict vegetarian diets, for instance, may carry unforeseen long-term risks to human metabolic functions. Moreover, some essential pharmaceuticalsvital medicines rely on compounds extracted from animal tissuesharvested from animal organs or blood, and these remain irreplaceable therapies for specific medical conditions. On the other hand, scientific progress has enabled many medications to be synthesised chemically in laboratoriespharmaceutical facilities or derived from plant sources, offering alternatives to animal-based drugs. Furthermore, killing animals for clothing is ethically indefensible. Modern textile manufacturing can produce synthetic fabrics that outperform animal-derived materials in functional propertiespractical attributes such as wrinkle-resistance and washability. Demand for fur and leather often stems from human vanity, as consumers seek to display social status through high-end animal-derived attireluxury animal-skin garments. From an environmental perspective, biodiversity underpinsBeyond ethical concerns, biodiversity underpins stable ecosystems. Should one species be driven to extinction, the resulting ripple effects couldShould one species be driven to extinction, ripple effects across food chains can trigger irreversible ecological damage, ultimately endangering human survival. In conclusion, strictly regulated animal usecontrolled animal slaughter for food and indispensable medicines is acceptable, but the production of animal-sourced clothing ought to be prohibited in the interests of long-term ecological balance.

Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 8.0

The essay presents a well-structured and nuanced position that directly addresses all parts of the prompt with sophisticated language and strong logical coherence. The primary limitation is the brief development of certain points due to word count constraints, particularly regarding alternative protein sources. To elevate the writing further, elaborate more deeply on counterarguments to strengthen the persuasion of the central thesis.

Band score breakdown

IELTS Writing Criteria Scores

TR

Task Response

8.0
Scoring rule

The response presents a clear, nuanced position that thoroughly addresses all aspects of the prompt, including food, clothing, and medicine.

Next step

Provide deeper analysis of modern alternatives like plant-based proteins to address the prompt's premise even more convincingly.

CC

Coherence and Cohesion

8.0
Scoring rule

Paragraphing is logical and ideas progress smoothly across the essay with effective use of cohesive devices.

Next step

Ensure transitions between supporting body paragraphs feel even more seamless by linking main themes directly.

LR

Lexical Resource

8.0
Scoring rule

A wide range of precise vocabulary and topic-specific collocations is used naturally and accurately throughout the response.

Next step

Maintain this high level of lexical sophistication while ensuring that all specialized terms remain contextually natural.

GRA

Grammatical Range and Accuracy

8.0
Scoring rule

The essay demonstrates a flexible mix of complex sentence structures with consistently high accuracy and control.

Next step

Continue employing varied grammatical structures while maintaining complete precision across longer, multi-clause sentences.

Put the feedback to work

Write this task while it is fresh

Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.

IELTS Writing Task 2

In modern society, it is no longer necessary to slaughter animals for producing foodstuffs, or non-food products such as clothes or medicine. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Your response

Words0
40:00

Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.