It is the responsibility of a government to protect its citizens from natural disasters. Do you agree or disagree?

Same question Compare 3 different answers (Band 6.5)

Sample Response

Natural disasters are sudden and cause severe damages. The impact is worst if citizens are unprepared to handle the disaster. Though natural disasters are unpredictable, they often follow a pattern. Based on the trend, disaster-prone areas can be classified and disaster management plan should include necessary preparedness to handle any such situation. I feel it is the responsibility of the government to protect its people from any natural calamities.

Only Government can frame a macro level policy to address various related issues related to disaster holistically. Though, the macro level policy can only be successful with micro-level initiatives and awareness. Hence, the government needs to involve its people so that they become aware of various stages of disaster management and need to disseminate the message properly that how the people can save their valuables and life in case of any natural calamities. The government can also ask for innovative proposals from its citizens on how to handle disasters as the nature of problem varies from area to area, it is important to consider those contextual complexities while designing a disaster management planning.

Proper weather forecasting system should be in place to generate the accurate forecasting and then the technological help should be taken to broadcast this information to the people. The aftermath of a disaster is always devastating and the government should take immediate steps to rescue the victim and provide aid to minimise the catastrophe.

The Government represents people of a country and act for the well-being of its population. Hence, to handle natural disaster cooperation between all the actors may it be the local government, civil society organisations, or local people are vital.

IELTS Writing Correction

  • 1. Use uncountable noun Original: damages Suggested revision: damage Why it matters: Damage is normally uncountable when referring generally to harm caused by disasters.
  • 2. Refer to patterns Original: Based on the trend Suggested revision: Based on these patterns Why it matters: Patterns more accurately refers to the recurring behaviour of different natural disasters.
  • 3. Add an article Original: classified and disaster management plan Suggested revision: classified and a disaster management plan Why it matters: A singular countable noun requires an article here.
  • 4. Use concrete noun Original: preparedness Suggested revision: preparations Why it matters: Preparations refers more naturally to the practical measures included in a plan.
  • 5. Fix number agreement Original: calamities Suggested revision: calamity Why it matters: Any takes a singular countable noun in this construction.
  • 6. Add definite article Original: Only Government Suggested revision: Only the government Why it matters: Government needs the definite article when it denotes the national institution.
  • 7. Remove repetition Original: various related issues related to disaster Suggested revision: various disaster-related issues Why it matters: The repeated use of related is redundant and weakens precision.
  • 8. Use correct connector Original: Though, the macro level policy Suggested revision: However, the macro-level policy Why it matters: Though cannot function as a standalone conjunctive adverb in this position.
  • 9. Repair clause structure Original: need to disseminate the message properly that how Suggested revision: must properly explain how Why it matters: That how is an ungrammatical combination introducing the indirect question.
  • 10. Use plural noun Original: life Suggested revision: lives Why it matters: Lives must be plural because the phrase refers to multiple people.
  • 11. Add definite article Original: nature of problem Suggested revision: nature of the problem Why it matters: The specific problem under discussion requires the definite article.
  • 12. Join clauses correctly Original: area to area, it is important Suggested revision: area to area, and it is important Why it matters: The conjunction prevents a comma splice between two independent clauses.

Suggested Rewrites

  • damages damage
  • Based on the trend Based on these patterns
  • classified and disaster management plan classified and a disaster management plan
  • preparedness preparations
  • calamities calamity
  • Only Government Only the government
Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 6.5

The response maintains a clear position and supports it with a well-organised range of governmental duties, from planning and public education to forecasting, rescue, and aid. Its main limitation is that several points remain general or repetitive, while recurring language errors weaken precision. Deepen one or two measures with concrete cause-and-effect explanation and edit complex sentences for grammatical completeness and cleaner wording.

Band score breakdown

IELTS Writing Criteria Scores

TR

Task Response

7.0
Scoring rule

The position is clear throughout, and several relevant governmental responsibilities are explained, though support remains somewhat general and repetitive.

Next step

Develop the strongest measures with specific examples showing how government action would reduce deaths, damage, or recovery time.

CC

Coherence and Cohesion

6.5
Scoring rule

Ideas progress logically through preparation, public involvement, forecasting, and response, but some paragraph transitions and internal links are mechanical or awkward.

Next step

Give each paragraph one clearly signposted function and connect supporting sentences through meaning rather than repeated linking words.

LR

Lexical Resource

6.5
Scoring rule

A good range of disaster-management vocabulary is used, although repetition and inaccurate collocations sometimes reduce precision and naturalness.

Next step

Replace awkward combinations with standard forms such as 'severe damage,' 'accurate forecasts,' 'technological tools,' and 'disaster-management plan.'

GRA

Grammatical Range and Accuracy

6.0
Scoring rule

The response uses varied complex structures, but recurring errors with articles, agreement, clause boundaries, and sentence construction limit accuracy.

Next step

Break overloaded sentences into complete clauses and proofread articles and subject-verb agreement before adding further complexity.

Put the feedback to work

Write this task while it is fresh

Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.

IELTS Writing Task 2

It is the responsibility of a government to protect its citizens from natural disasters. Do you agree or disagree?

Your response

Words0
40:00

Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.