Many employees are now required to wear a uniform as part of their company policy and this has many significant advantages. What is your viewpoint on this issue? Do the advantages of it outweigh the disadvantages?

Same question Compare 4 different answers (Band 5.5–6)

Sample Response

Today, wearing the uniform is becoming standard in almost all companies and organisations, especially manufacturing sectors. Some people think this move is good, whereas some think the opposite. I will discuss both the advantages and disadvantages of this, in below paragraphs.

On the one hand, many companies like the nuclear plant, automobile manufacturing plant, fertiliser plant, refineries, often insist their employees wear a uniform. This has advantages, as workers feel united and make them deliver best results. The uniform is tailored in such a way that it will help the employees in emergency situations. Also, this type of uniform will promote the company brand when the customer sees them. In addition, customers will have a positive mindset about the company when they see employees in uniform. This will increase the company reputation in public as well as its growth.

On the other hand, the specific tailoring method of the company uniform makes the employees feel discomfort. Sometimes, this type of stitching doesn't suit some employees’ physical appearance. This will result in the lack of concentrations of employees on their job, which in turn result in the decline in company performance. In some cases, people resign from their job for this reason only. This increase in attrition rate will result in companies’ negative growth, as it is difficult to hire skilled personnel easily.

To sum up, I feel that strict rule for wearing a uniform in companies is not fair. Before implementing a uniform, a company should take opinion from their employees and consider their suggestions. Also, the company should explain the benefits of the uniform to their employees. In this way, both companies and employees’ thought will be respected.

IELTS Writing Correction

  • 1. Use indefinite article Original: the Suggested revision: a Why it matters: The first general reference to a uniform requires the indefinite article.
  • 2. Add sector preposition Original: especially manufacturing sectors Suggested revision: especially in manufacturing sectors Why it matters: The context requires “in” to locate the practice within those sectors.
  • 3. Clarify opposing group Original: whereas some think the opposite Suggested revision: whereas others disagree Why it matters: The replacement avoids repeating “some” and states the contrast directly.
  • 4. Fix paragraph phrase Original: of this, in below paragraphs Suggested revision: of this in the paragraphs below Why it matters: The definite article and adjective position are required in this locative phrase.
  • 5. Make purpose concise Original: The uniform is tailored in such a way that it will help Suggested revision: The uniform is designed to help Why it matters: The revision states the intended protective purpose directly and concisely.
  • 6. Use possessive form Original: company Suggested revision: company's Why it matters: The brand belongs to the company, so a possessive form is required.
  • 7. Clarify pronoun reference Original: when the customer sees them Suggested revision: when customers see employees wearing it Why it matters: The revision fixes the number mismatch and makes both pronoun references explicit.
  • 8. Fix impression collocation Original: positive mindset about Suggested revision: positive impression of Why it matters: Customers form an “impression of” a company rather than a mindset about it.
  • 9. Fix reputation phrase Original: increase the company reputation in public Suggested revision: improve the company's public reputation Why it matters: A reputation is improved, and the possessive structure is more natural.
  • 10. Use design term Original: specific tailoring method Suggested revision: specific design Why it matters: “Design” describes the uniform's cut and construction more naturally than “tailoring method.”
  • 11. Use adjective complement Original: makes the employees feel discomfort Suggested revision: makes employees feel uncomfortable Why it matters: “Feel” takes the adjective “uncomfortable,” and the general plural noun needs no article.
  • 12. Remove awkward appearance phrase Original: doesn't suit some employees’ physical appearance Suggested revision: does not suit some employees Why it matters: A uniform can suit a person directly, so the extra phrase is unnecessary.

Suggested Rewrites

  • the a
  • especially manufacturing sectors especially in manufacturing sectors
  • whereas some think the opposite whereas others disagree
  • of this, in below paragraphs of this in the paragraphs below
  • The uniform is tailored in such a way that it will help The uniform is designed to help
  • company company's
Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 6.0

The response presents a clear advantages-and-disadvantages structure and offers relevant points about safety, branding, comfort, and staff retention. Its main limitation is that it never directly decides whether the advantages outweigh the disadvantages; the conclusion only rejects a strict rule and recommends consultation. Prioritise an explicit comparative position and justify it by weighing the most important benefit against the strongest drawback.

Band score breakdown

IELTS Writing Criteria Scores

TR

Task Response

5.5
Scoring rule

Relevant advantages and disadvantages are discussed and a viewpoint is implied, but the required judgement about which side outweighs the other is not clearly answered.

Next step

State directly whether the benefits outweigh the drawbacks and explain why safety or comfort carries greater overall importance.

CC

Coherence and Cohesion

6.5
Scoring rule

The four-paragraph structure and progression from benefits to drawbacks are clear, although some supporting claims connect mechanically or weakly.

Next step

End each body paragraph by linking its strongest point to the overall comparison required by the question.

LR

Lexical Resource

6.0
Scoring rule

The essay uses sufficient workplace vocabulary, but repetition and inaccurate collocations limit flexibility and precision.

Next step

Replace phrases such as 'feel discomfort', 'lack of concentrations', 'negative growth', and 'take opinion' with natural alternatives.

GRA

Grammatical Range and Accuracy

5.5
Scoring rule

Meaning is generally clear, but recurring errors with articles, agreement, plurals, and verb forms are noticeable throughout.

Next step

Check subject-verb agreement and noun forms in sentences about uniforms, employees, concentration, and company performance.

Put the feedback to work

Write this task while it is fresh

Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.

IELTS Writing Task 2

Many employees are now required to wear a uniform as part of their company policy and this has many significant advantages. What is your viewpoint on this issue? Do the advantages of it outweigh the disadvantages?

Your response

Words0
40:00

Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.