The growth of online shopping will one day lead to all shops in towns and cities closing. Do you agree or disagree?
Sample Response
With the rapid expansion of e-commerce, many speculate that traditional brick-and-mortar stores will eventually disappear. However, despite its dominance, I firmly believe that physical shops will continue to exist, as they provide irreplaceable advantages such as sensory shopping experiences and immediate product access. In this essay, I will explain why.
One key reason why physical stores will not vanish is that they offer a physical and immersive shopping experience that online platforms cannot replicate. Customers value the ability to see, touch, and try products before making a purchase, particularly for items such as clothing, furniture, and electronics. In contrast, online shopping often results in dissatisfaction due to discrepancies between expectations and reality. For example, many consumers have reported receiving clothes that do not fit as expected, leading to inconvenient returns. This fundamental aspect of human psychology - the need to interact with products before buying, ensures the survival of physical stores.
Another crucial factor is the immediacy of in-store purchases, which remains a significant advantage over e-commerce. While online retailers have made strides in fast delivery, even same-day shipping cannot always meet the urgency of certain consumer needs. Grocery stores, pharmacies, and hardware shops, for instance, provide essential goods instantly, which is particularly vital in emergencies. For example, if someone needs a crucial medication, waiting for an online order is impractical, making local stores indispensable.
In conclusion, despite the growing influence of online shopping, physical stores will persist due to the need for direct product interaction and immediate accessibility. Therefore, the idea that all shops will eventually close is an overstatement rather than an inevitable outcome.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Natural growth phrase Original: expansion Suggested revision: growth Why it matters: This is a more natural collocation for the increasing scale of e-commerce.
- 2. Clarify the reference Original: despite its dominance Suggested revision: despite the growing dominance of e-commerce Why it matters: Naming e-commerce directly removes the slightly unclear pronoun reference.
- 3. Avoid overstatement Original: irreplaceable Suggested revision: distinct Why it matters: This wording states the contrast precisely without making an absolute claim.
- 4. Use natural phrasing Original: sensory shopping experiences Suggested revision: hands-on shopping experiences Why it matters: This phrase more naturally describes seeing, touching, and trying products.
- 5. Reduce lexical overlap Original: physical and immersive shopping experience Suggested revision: hands-on shopping experience Why it matters: The revision expresses direct product interaction more concisely.
- 6. Make contrast concrete Original: discrepancies between expectations and reality Suggested revision: differences between what customers expect and what they receive Why it matters: The revision makes the source of dissatisfaction more specific.
- 7. Improve the collocation Original: leading to inconvenient returns Suggested revision: resulting in the inconvenience of returns Why it matters: The noun phrase more naturally describes the burden caused by unsuitable purchases.
- 8. Close the parenthesis Original: psychology - the need to interact with products before buying, Suggested revision: psychology—the need to interact with products before buying— Why it matters: The explanatory phrase needs matching punctuation rather than a hyphen and a comma.
- 9. Improve the collocation Original: made strides in fast delivery Suggested revision: made strides in speeding up delivery Why it matters: This revision uses a more natural expression for delivery improvements.
- 10. Use concise wording Original: meet the urgency of certain consumer needs Suggested revision: meet certain urgent consumer needs Why it matters: The revision expresses the same idea more directly.
- 11. Express urgency clearly Original: needs a crucial medication Suggested revision: urgently needs medication Why it matters: The adverb describes the time-sensitive need more naturally than 'crucial' describes the medication.
- 12. Use the standard noun Original: accessibility Suggested revision: access Why it matters: 'Access' is the more natural noun for the ability to obtain products immediately.
Suggested Rewrites
- expansion growth
- despite its dominance despite the growing dominance of e-commerce
- irreplaceable distinct
- sensory shopping experiences hands-on shopping experiences
- physical and immersive shopping experience hands-on shopping experience
- discrepancies between expectations and reality differences between what customers expect and what they receive
Why this response received Band 8.0
The response presents a clear, consistent disagreement and supports it with two relevant, well-developed reasons in a polished and logically organised argument. Its main limitation is that a few claims are somewhat broad and one complex sentence has faulty punctuation, so the highest-priority improvement is to sharpen the evidence and proofread complex punctuation while preserving the concise development.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
The position directly answers the question and is sustained through two relevant, well-developed reasons with appropriate examples.
Make supporting claims more specific by grounding broad statements about consumers or human psychology in tighter explanation.
Coherence and Cohesion
Ideas progress logically through a clear introduction, focused body paragraphs, and a conclusion that follows naturally from the argument.
Refine the internal link between the clothing example and the broader claim so the reasoning is even more seamless.
Lexical Resource
Vocabulary is wide, precise, and natural, with effective topic-specific choices such as sensory experience, immediacy, and indispensable.
Avoid slightly inflated wording such as describing e-commerce as dominant when a more measured term would be more exact.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A wide range of complex structures is used accurately, and the few errors do not affect clarity.
Proofread punctuation around parenthetical explanations, especially the unnecessary comma before ensures in the second paragraph.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
The growth of online shopping will one day lead to all shops in towns and cities closing. Do you agree or disagree?
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.