Some people think that good health is very important to every person, so medical services should not be run by profit-making companies. Do the advantages of private health care outweigh the disadvantages?
Sample Response
Good health is central to a fulfilling lifeundeniably a cornerstone of a fulfilling life, and many argue that it should be safeguarded from profit-driven healthcare providersprofit-driven interests. While there might be valid concernssome valid concerns about the ethicsmorality of this business model, I firmly believe that the advantages are far more significant than the disadvantagesfar more significant.
Critics of private healthcare often express ethical concerns about the profit-driven natureethical concerns related to the profit-driven nature of these institutions. They may argue that profit motives in private healthcare can lead tocan sometimes give rise to overmedicalization and unnecessary procedures. In a competitive market, there may be incentives to recommend additional tests or treatments, potentially exposing patients to risks and financial burdens. These concerns, however, are often limited to the very most extreme situations, and not applicable to the vast majority of private healthcare facilities which still successfully maintain high ethical standards, prioritizing patient welfare over profit margins, and delivering quality care without unnecessary intervention.
In my opinion, private healthcare can be more beneficial in terms of a higher quality of services and personalized careindividualized experiences. Private institutions often compete for patients, driving them to invest in state-of-the-art facilities, employ skilled professionals, and adopt cutting-edge treatments, resulting in quicker access to care, reduced waiting times, and a broader range of treatment options. Additionally, private healthcare can offer personalized attentiona level of personalized attention and comfort that may be lacking in public facilities. With a lower patient-to-staff ratio, medical practitioners can devote more time to individual cases, enabling them to develop tailored treatment plans that support patient well-beingenabling tailored treatment plans for patient well-being.
In conclusion, although there might be some instances where profit motives may lead to overmedicalization, these cases represent the exception rather than the rule. The potential for higher quality services and personalized care makesmake private healthcare a valuable complement to public services.
Why this response received Band 7.5
The response presents a clear position and develops a coherent comparison, with especially effective explanation of how competition can improve service quality and personalised care. The main limitation is that the disadvantage is dismissed as exceptional without enough support, so the weighing feels slightly asserted; directly comparing the scale or likelihood of the identified harm with the benefits would make the conclusion more convincing.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
The response addresses both advantages and disadvantages, maintains a clear position, and develops the principal benefits in relevant detail.
Justify why overmedicalisation is less significant by explicitly weighing its prevalence or severity against the stated benefits.
Coherence and Cohesion
The argument progresses clearly from position to disadvantage, advantages, and conclusion, with cohesive links managed effectively.
Shorten the long final sentence of the disadvantage paragraph so its concession and rebuttal are easier to follow.
Lexical Resource
Vocabulary is varied and generally precise, including effective language for ethics, competition, treatment, and patient care.
Replace slightly awkward combinations such as very most extreme situations and individualized experiences with more natural phrasing.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
Complex sentences are frequent and mostly well controlled, with only occasional agreement and sentence-structure lapses.
Check agreement in phrases such as the potential ... makes and avoid attaching a non-finite list to an already overloaded sentence.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people think that good health is very important to every person, so medical services should not be run by profit-making companies. Do the advantages of private health care outweigh the disadvantages?
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.