Air travel is one of the main reasons for increasing air pollution these days. So restricting air travel is the only way to prevent air pollution. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Sample Response
Some people suggest that air travel is one of the main culprits for worseningescalating air pollution these days, and restricting air travel is the only possible way to control air pollution. While air travel undeniably contributes to air pollution, it cannot be singled out as the sole culprit and its curtailment, while tempting, presents an overly simplistic solution to a complex environmental challenge.
Firstly, attributing air pollution solely to air travel fails to acknowledge the substantial contributions fromof other sectors. Ground transportation, particularly fossil-fuel-powered vehicles, remains a major source of emissions. Industrial activities, from energy production to manufacturing, also emit substantial amounts of pollutantsspew substantial pollutants into the atmosphere. Focusing solely on aviation misses the wider picture and risks neglecting crucial opportunities to reduce emissionscrucial areas for emissions reduction. For instance, investing in electric vehicles and public transportation infrastructure could yield far greater benefits for air quality than limiting flights alonethan solely limiting flights.
Moreover, restricting air travel would impose significant economic and social consequences. Global connectivity, facilitated by air travel, fuels international trade, fosters cultural exchange and drives tourism-dependent economies. Imposing severe limitations on these airborne linksair-borne links could stifle economic growth, isolate communities, and hinder global collaboration in fields such as medicinefields like medicine and research. For example, restricting medical evacuation flights during a pandemic could drastically worsen the pandemic's impactworsen its impact, highlighting the potential downsides of a blanket ban on air travel. Instead of resorting to draconian measures, a comprehensive approach that promotes cleaner technologies and operational improvements within the aviation industry holds greater promise.
In conclusion, while air travel's contribution to air pollution cannot be ignored, identifyingattributing it as the sole culprit and proposing its radical curtailment is a misguided approach. Focusing solely on restricting flights overlooks the broader range of air-pollution sourceswider canvas of air pollution sources and risks jeopardizing global connectivity and economic progress. A multi-pronged strategy that embraces cleaner technologies, operational improvements within aviation, and targeted efforts in other sectors offers a more effective path towards bettercleaner air quality.
Why this response received Band 8.5
The response directly challenges the claim, develops two substantial lines of reasoning, and sustains a persuasive position with well-chosen examples. Its main limitation is minor repetition and occasional imprecision, such as the medical-flight example's unclear reference, rather than any major gap in coverage. The highest priority is to tighten repeated points in the conclusion and refine the few awkward collocations or ambiguous references.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
The position is direct and fully developed through relevant analysis of alternative pollution sources and the consequences of restricting flights.
Make the medical-flight example more directly representative of the broader social costs of restricting ordinary air travel.
Coherence and Cohesion
The response is skilfully organised, with clear paragraph purposes and cohesive progression from causes to consequences and alternatives.
Condense the conclusion so it synthesises the argument without repeating several phrases and claims from earlier paragraphs.
Lexical Resource
A wide, precise vocabulary is used flexibly, with only occasional awkwardness or unnecessary repetition.
Refine isolated expressions such as "cleaner air quality" and reduce repeated use of "solely" for still greater precision.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A wide range of complex structures is handled accurately, and the few errors or ambiguities do not impede communication.
Check pronoun references and constructions such as "attributing it as" so every complex sentence remains fully precise.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Air travel is one of the main reasons for increasing air pollution these days. So restricting air travel is the only way to prevent air pollution. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.