Some people think history has nothing or little to tell us, but others think that studying history can help us better understand the present. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
Sample Response
The value of history, especially whether it provides essential insights into current events, is a topic of ongoing debate. Even though some might argue that it has little relevance to modern life, I firmly support the view that understanding history is crucial for comprehending the present.
On the one hand, there are reasons to downplay the merit of knowing history. Proponents of this viewThe proponents of this claim, firstly, may point to the fact that contemporary society is far removed from the past. Technological advancesadvancement and social change might have made historical lessons obsolete, because several forces shaping the worldfor several driving elements of the world, such as geopolitics and the digital economy, are unlike anything experienced by pre-industrial societies. Furthermore, history may hinder progress by keeping society fixated on outdated ideas and conflicts, rather than encouraging innovation and forward-thinking. With too much dwelling on the past, whether success or failure, and insufficient motivation for progress, society will likely fail to produce breakthroughs that improve people's livesproduce breakthroughs for the lives of its members.
However, it would be ill-advised to discard history on those grounds. Today, knowledge of historythe knowledge from this subject continues to provide invaluable context for understanding current events and societal trends. Many ongoing political struggles and conflicts are deeply rooted in disputes documented in historical recordsfeuds that were well-recorded in history. Therefore, only by examining the causes and consequences of those past disputes can mankind formulate proper strategies for addressing them in the present. History, in addition, is an encyclopedia of human behavior, governance, and ethics that remain relevant despite changes in technology and society. Understanding the successes and failures of past civilizations can guide world leaders in making informed decisions, especially decisions that benefit both present and future generationsespecially ones that benefit not only their current but also future generations.
In conclusion, even though a case can be made for dismissing history as irrelevant, humanity does itself a disservicemankind does a disservice to itself by doing so, for this subject offers valuable insights for the present day. As history is so consequential for navigating the modern era, it should remain a fundamental component of education and public discourse.
Why this response received Band 8.0
The response is strongest in its balanced, clearly signposted discussion and sustained position, with both perspectives developed through relevant causal reasoning. Its main limitation is that several claims remain broad and somewhat abstract, and a few expressions are less natural than the otherwise precise style. The highest-priority improvement is to support the central arguments with a more concrete historical example and tighten occasional awkward collocations.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
Both views and a clear opinion are fully addressed through relevant, well-developed reasoning.
Add one specific historical case to make the support more concrete and persuasive.
Coherence and Cohesion
The essay progresses logically through a clear introduction, contrasting body sections, and a consistent conclusion.
Make the movement from general claims to supporting details slightly more explicit within each body paragraph.
Lexical Resource
A wide and precise vocabulary conveys complex ideas effectively, despite a few slightly awkward collocations.
Replace expressions such as broad references to the world's driving elements with more natural, exact wording.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A broad range of complex structures is used accurately and with strong control throughout.
Refine occasional compressed constructions so that sophisticated sentences remain fully natural as well as accurate.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people think history has nothing or little to tell us, but others think that studying history can help us better understand the present. Discuss both views and give your opinion.
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.