Some people believe that old buildings should be protected by law. Others, however, think that they should be replaced by new buildings. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Sample Response
In today's world, the debate over the fate of old buildings continues to be a contentious issue. Some people argue that old buildings should be protectedpreserved and protected by law, while others maintain that these buildings should be replaced by new ones. This essay will examine both views and provide reasons why I believe that old buildings that are important and historically significant shouldold buildings, that are important and have historic significance should be protected by law.
On the one hand, those who advocate for replacing old buildings with new onesnew buildings in place of old ones contend that old buildings are often outdated and pose a riskdanger to public safety. These buildings may have faulty electrical systems, weak structures, and outdated plumbing, making them unsafe to occupyunsuitable for habitation. In addition, they argue that new buildings are more energy-efficient and environmentally friendly, reducing theirthe carbon footprint and making cities more sustainable. For instance, despite their historic significance, many old structures in Japan were replaced by modern buildings to improve earthquake safetyto ensure safety against earthquakes.
On the other hand, those who support the preservation of old buildings argue that they have significant cultural and historical valuea significant cultural and historical value that cannot be replaced. Old buildings often serve as a tangible link to the past, showcasing the architectural and design trends of a particular perioda particular time period. These buildings also have a unique character and charm that new buildings simply cannot replicate. Furthermore, preserving old buildings can help to maintain the identity of a city or region and attract tourists, contributing to the local economy. For instance, old towns and their medieval structures are often the main tourist attractions in our country.
In my opinion, old buildings should be protected by law. While it is true that some old buildings may need significant renovations to ensure their safety and functionality, it is important to preserve the historical and cultural significance of important old buildings. The loss of old buildings can result in the erasure of a city's cultural and architectural heritage, which is irreplaceable.
In conclusion, while there are valid arguments for both sides of the debate, I believe that old buildings should be protected by law. This will ensure that their cultural and historical significance is preserved for future generations, while also helpingcontributing to boost tourism.
Why this response received Band 8.0
The essay addresses both views directly, sustains a clear opinion, and develops its arguments with relevant explanations and examples in a well-organised structure. Its main limitation is occasional imprecision or awkwardness in otherwise flexible language, particularly in a few collocations and sentence constructions. Refine those local expressions and add slightly more nuanced evaluation of which old buildings merit legal protection.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
Both views are fully addressed, and the writer's consistent opinion is supported with relevant reasons and examples.
Add a more precise principle for deciding which historically significant buildings deserve protection despite safety concerns.
Coherence and Cohesion
Ideas are logically sequenced in well-focused paragraphs, and cohesive devices guide the reader without obscuring progression.
Reduce minor repetition of old buildings and make the final opinion paragraph add more synthesis before the conclusion.
Lexical Resource
A broad, topic-appropriate vocabulary conveys ideas precisely overall, with only occasional awkward collocations and repetition.
Refine phrases such as contributing to boost tourism and vary repeated key nouns where clarity permits.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
The essay uses varied complex structures with strong control, though a few punctuation and construction errors remain.
Review relative-clause punctuation and verb patterns, especially structures following contribute and embedded modifiers.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people believe that old buildings should be protected by law. Others, however, think that they should be replaced by new buildings. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.