Some people think that governments should pay for education and health care, while others believe that it is not their responsibility. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Sample Response
Opinions are divided on whether the funding of essential public services, namely education and healthcare, should be the exclusive responsibility of the state or whether individuals should bearor individuals should bear a portion of the cost. While state funding is fundamental, I believe a hybrid model that includes individual contributions is ultimately more sustainable and fosters greater accountability.
Proponents of state-funded education and healthcare argue that it is a fundamental government duty that is essential fora fundamental government duty essential for a just and prosperous society. The primary argument concerns ensuring equal accessThe primary argument is the assurance of equal access for all social groups. State funding effectively removes financial barriers, thereby providing equal opportunities for individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds. For instance, publicly funded hospitals and schools ensure that low-income families can receive necessary medical treatment and quality education, which can be a meanscornerstone of promoting social equity. Furthermore, such public investment is crucialthis investment is believed to be crucial for national development. This is because a healthy and well-educated populace can lead tologically leads to higher productivity and greater innovation, fueling long-term economic growth, as exemplified by Nordic countries, which investNordic countries which invest heavily in these sectors and consistently rank high in living standards.
Despite this, I strongly believe that individuals should bear some responsibility for these services for several reasons. Chief among these is that fully free systems risk becoming inefficient or generating excessive demandfully free systems risk inefficiency or excessive demand, which can severely strain public budgets and, consequently, reduce service quality. This is evident in the hospital overcrowding seenthe overcrowded public hospitals seen in many developing Asian nationsAsian developing nations, where limited resources directly result in longer waiting times. Moreover, requiring individuals to contribute financially can encourage personal responsibility and choice. When people contribute, they arguably value services more and make more informed decisions. This greater engagement can fosterThis increased awareness can foster personal accountability and a more efficient use of resources, reducing dependencedependency on public funding.
In conclusion, while the state has a vital obligation to fund healthcare and education to guarantee universal access and drive national advancement, in my opinion, this responsibility need not be absolute. The most effective and sustainable model is a balanced one, where government provision of essential services is supplemented by individual contributions to ensure long-term viability and promote personal responsibility.
Why this response received Band 8.5
The response presents a sophisticated, well-balanced discussion with a consistent hybrid position, fully developed explanations, and highly controlled academic language. Its main limitation is minor imprecision in a few collocations and some repetition of ideas about responsibility and sustainability. The priority is to sharpen these formulations and make the opposing view's claim that funding is not a state responsibility slightly more explicit.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Task Response
Both views and a nuanced personal position are fully addressed through relevant, extended, and convincing reasoning.
Make the argument for minimal government responsibility more explicit before presenting the preferred hybrid model.
Coherence and Cohesion
Information is sequenced seamlessly, with clear paragraph purposes and well-controlled cohesive devices throughout.
Trim small repetitions of responsibility and sustainability to make the progression even more economical.
Lexical Resource
The vocabulary is extensive and precise, though a few combinations are slightly awkward or formulaic.
Refine phrases such as 'a cornerstone of promoting social equity' to achieve consistently natural precision.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
Complex sentence forms are varied, flexible, and highly accurate, with only rare minor lapses.
Polish occasional overloaded sentences by simplifying embedded clauses while preserving the sophisticated argument.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people think that governments should pay for education and health care, while others believe that it is not their responsibility. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.