The map below is of the town of Garlsdon. A new supermarket (S) is planned for the town. The map shows two possible sites for the supermarket.

Same questionCompare 2 different answers (Band 6)

Sample Response

1

The given map shows two possible locations for the planned supermarket in GarlsdonGarsdon City. As is presented in the illustration, the city has a population of more than 65 thousand and the two possible locations for the supermarket are near Hindon area and in the middle of the industrial area.

2

Overall, the first location (S1) would be both away from the town centre and out of the crowd, which would be more convenient for the citizens of HindonHindson area, while the second location (S2) would be advantageous for the people of Bransdon and Cransdon area. According to the map, the railway runs through the cityrailway surrounds the city and passes close to the town centre and S2intersects the city almost in the middle. There are main roads for transportation and countryside surrounds the main housing areasmain housings and industries of the city. The housing of the city is mainly in the North and South sides of the city and the town centre is surrounded by the built-up areatown centre is in the middle of the industrial area. The first possible location for the planned supermarket is near the Hindon area where almost ten thousand inhabitants live and the location is in the north-west corner. This location would be ideal for the Hindon people for shopping but the people of Cransdon and BransdonCrandon and Brandon, which have much larger populationsgreat more population, would be far away from this supermarket. The second possible location which is almost in the centre of the city would be surrounded by industrial zones and housing areashousings in the North and South sides of the city. This would be an ideal place as it would connect shoppers from Garlsdon and the nearby townsall the shoppers in the three parts of the city. Since the railway passes near this location, this would be a better place in terms of communication as well.

Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 6.0

The response covers both proposed sites and provides a generally logical account of their surrounding settlements and transport links. Its main limitation is that some convenience claims go beyond the map and several visual details are inaccurate, particularly the description of the railway. Prioritise a direct evidence-based comparison: S1 is outside the town near Hindon and the railway, whereas S2 is central within the no-traffic zone.

Band score breakdown

IELTS Writing Criteria Scores

TA

Task Achievement

6.0
Scoring rule

The response describes both sites and the surrounding settlements, but it over-interprets convenience and makes some visual inaccuracies, especially saying the railway surrounds the city. It should focus more on S1 being outside the town/countryside and S2 being in the town centre/no traffic zone.

Next step

Revise by comparing access: S1 is northwest near Hindon and the railway, while S2 is central in the no-traffic town centre and closer to Garlsdon residents.

CC

Coherence and Cohesion

6.5
Scoring rule

The answer has paragraphs and a generally logical map description, although some information is repeated and the evaluative comments are not always tied to map evidence.

Next step

Keep one overview and group details by site rather than moving between roads, housing, and nearby towns repeatedly.

LR

Lexical Resource

6.0
Scoring rule

Vocabulary is adequate for map description, but several names are misspelled and phrases such as 'great more population' and 'housings' are unnatural.

Next step

Use exact place names from the map: Garlsdon, Hindon, Bransdon, and Cransdon; use 'housing areas' instead of 'housings'.

GRA

Grammatical Range and Accuracy

6.0
Scoring rule

Grammar is generally clear, but there are article errors, awkward relative clauses, and several long sentences with overloaded comparisons.

Next step

Shorten sentences and use direct comparisons: 'S1 is closer to Hindon, whereas S2 is more central for Garlsdon residents'.

Put the feedback to work

Write this task while it is fresh

Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.

IELTS Academic Writing Task 1

The map below is of the town of Garlsdon. A new supermarket (S) is planned for the town. The map shows two possible sites for the supermarket.

Your response

Words0
20:00

Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.