Some people argue that primary schools focus too much on formal learning. To what extent do you agree with this opinion? How important do you think it is for children to play as well as learn in the primary school classroom?
Same question Compare all 3 answers See different approaches and band scores for this IELTS task.Sample Response
It is sometimes claimed that primary education gives too much attention to formal subjects, such as maths and literacy. I partly agree with this view, because basic academic skills are necessary, but children also need regular opportunities to play in the classroom.
On the one hand, schools cannot ignore formal learning in the early years. Reading, writing and simple calculations are foundations for almost every subject that pupils will study later. If these skills are not taught systematically, children from homes where parents have little time or money to support learning may fall behind their classmates. In addition, a clear lesson structure can help young learners understand what is expected of them and make progress. Therefore, it would be unrealistic to replace formal teaching entirely with games.
However, many primary schools may organise the day too much like secondary education. Young children have a limited ability to sit still and concentrate for long periods. As a result, worksheets and teacher-led lessons can make them bored, even when the material itself is useful. Play is not simply a break from education. For example, when children build something together or act out a story, they practise communication, problem solving and cooperation. These abilities are difficult to develop through individual written exercises alone. Playful activities can also allow quieter pupils to participate without being afraid of giving a wrong answer in front of the whole class.
In my opinion, learning and play should be combined rather than treated as opposites. A teacher could use a shop game to teach addition, or ask groups to create a short drama after reading a book. Such activities still have educational aims, but they are more suitable for the way many children learn. Formal lessons remain important, although primary classrooms should give play a central role if schools want to support both academic achievement and social development.
IELTS Writing Correction
- 1. Remove the comma Original: , because Suggested revision: because Why it matters: The because-clause is integral to the reason for partial agreement, so no comma is needed.
- 2. Use natural collocation Original: are foundations for almost every subject Suggested revision: form the foundation for almost every subject Why it matters: The expression 'form the foundation for' is more idiomatic in this context.
- 3. Clarify the reference Original: children from homes where parents have little time or money to support learning Suggested revision: children whose parents have little time or money to support their learning Why it matters: The relative construction links the parents directly to the children and clarifies whose learning is supported.
- 4. Sharpen the comparison Original: organise the day too much like secondary education Suggested revision: structure the day too much like secondary schools do Why it matters: This phrasing compares how the two types of school organise the day rather than comparing a day with education.
- 5. Use natural phrasing Original: make them bored Suggested revision: make them feel bored Why it matters: The revised collocation sounds more natural when describing the children's response.
- 6. Use a stronger verb Original: can also allow quieter pupils to participate Suggested revision: can also enable quieter pupils to participate Why it matters: 'Enable' expresses the idea more concisely without changing the claim.
- 7. Make wording concise Original: without being afraid of giving a wrong answer Suggested revision: without fear of giving a wrong answer Why it matters: The shorter noun phrase preserves the meaning and improves concision.
- 8. Remove the comma Original: addition, or ask Suggested revision: addition or ask Why it matters: A comma is unnecessary between two verb phrases that share the same subject and modal verb.
- 9. Use precise phrasing Original: more suitable for the way many children learn Suggested revision: better suited to the way many children learn Why it matters: 'Better suited to' is the more natural comparative expression here.
- 10. Use academic phrasing Original: gives too much attention to Suggested revision: places too much emphasis on Why it matters: This collocation is more natural and precise in a discussion of educational priorities.
- 11. Use precise wording Original: simple calculations Suggested revision: basic calculations Why it matters: 'Basic' more clearly describes the foundational level of the calculations.
- 12. Use a direct structure Original: have a limited ability to sit still and concentrate for long periods Suggested revision: find it difficult to sit still and concentrate for long periods Why it matters: The revised construction expresses the limitation more directly and naturally.
Suggested Rewrites
- , because because
- are foundations for almost every subject form the foundation for almost every subject
- children from homes where parents have little time or money to support learning children whose parents have little time or money to support their learning
- organise the day too much like secondary education structure the day too much like secondary schools do
- make them bored make them feel bored
- can also allow quieter pupils to participate can also enable quieter pupils to participate
Why this response received Band 8.0
The essay's strongest feature is its balanced, clearly sustained position, developed through relevant explanations and concrete classroom examples. Its main limitation is that the extent of agreement with the claim about excessive formal learning could be stated more explicitly when the argument turns from recognising academic necessities to criticising current practice. Prioritise sharpening that evaluation so the nuanced conclusion follows even more directly from the preceding discussion.
IELTS Writing Criteria Scores
Detailed feedback by IELTS writing criterion after the annotated essay.
Task Response
Both questions are fully addressed through a clear, nuanced position and well-developed, relevant support.
State more explicitly how widespread or serious the excessive focus on formal learning is to sharpen the degree of agreement.
Coherence and Cohesion
Ideas progress logically through a balanced discussion, and paragraphing and referencing make the argument easy to follow.
Make the link between the critique of secondary-style teaching and the final combined approach slightly more explicit.
Lexical Resource
Vocabulary is wide, precise and natural, particularly in describing educational methods, participation and child development.
Continue refining evaluative language so distinctions such as necessary structure versus excessive formality are expressed even more precisely.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
A wide range of complex structures is handled accurately and flexibly, with consistently clear sentences.
Maintain this strong control while varying the form of conditional and concessive structures in future arguments.
Write this task while it is fresh
Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.
IELTS Writing Task 2
Some people argue that primary schools focus too much on formal learning. To what extent do you agree with this opinion? How important do you think it is for children to play as well as learn in the primary school classroom?
Your response
Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.