The best way to provide enough homes in large cities is to build tall apartment blocks. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?

Same questionCompare 8 different answers (Band 5–8)

Sample Response

1

As adequate accessAs the adequate access to housing in large cities has become a serious problem recently, it is argued that the best approach to address this issue is to build tall apartment blocks. In my opinion, despite the advantages it offers in relievingadvantages it brings to relieve the housing problem, it is not the best solution considering its negative impacts on urban infrastructureside effects to the city infrastructures and potential safety risks.

2

Arguments in favor of such a proposal holdArguments in favor of such proposal holds that with an increasing number of peoplenumber people seeking to dwell in cities nowadays, the traditional low-density housing modeloriginal building pattern cannot accommodate more residents. Tall apartment blocks, in contrast, havehas the capability of offering far more homes than the traditional low-rise buildingsformer buildings, on the same footprint of landgiven the same acres of land. In this way, as advocatesadvocators argue, city residents' housing can be arranged in a higher density, thereby solving the problem of housing shortageshome insufficiency.

3

However, what this plan overlooks are the consequences for city infrastructureconsequences to the city infrastructures and potential security threats that come with it. If far more people were to be accommodated in a small urban area, the demand for transportneed for traffic, water and other public resources would surge to a destructive level that no existing infrastructures can endure, leading to an overall breakdown in the city'sa overall break to city's public services. For example, when more people live downtownlive in downtown, the everyday traffic will be chaotic with a massive number of cars jammed on the roads, not to mention the substantial demand for electricity that may exhaust power plants. Moreover, having too many tall apartment blocks also means significantly greater pressure on the groundlarger pressure to the soil. If the underlying ground failsOnce the background fails to hold that much weight, the buildings may threaten to collapse, causing unimaginable casualties.

4

In conclusion, despite the increasingly concerning housing problem in reality, building tall apartment blocks is in no way the best solution to adopttake, because we cannot overlook the excessive burden on city infrastructures and the potential risks to people's livesdamages to people's life that will come along once put into practice.

Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 7.5

The essay presents a well-structured argument with a clear, consistent stance that addresses the prompt directly, supporting its position with logical explanations and examples. To reach a higher standard, the response would benefit from discussing alternative solutions to contrast against building tall blocks and refining grammatical accuracy regarding subject-verb agreement and article usage.

Band score breakdown

IELTS Writing Criteria Scores

TR

Task Response

7.5
Scoring rule

You establish a clear position early on and develop relevant supporting arguments regarding the limitations and risks of high-rise developments.

Next step

Briefly mention or compare alternative ways to provide urban housing to more thoroughly address why tall apartment blocks are not the absolute best approach.

CC

Coherence and Cohesion

7.5
Scoring rule

Paragraphs are logically organized with clear main ideas and effective linking words that ensure smooth transitions throughout the response.

Next step

Vary your cohesive devices further and ensure referencing within paragraphs remains natural and precise.

LR

Lexical Resource

7.0
Scoring rule

A good range of topic-specific vocabulary is used flexibly to explain complex ideas about urban planning and infrastructure.

Next step

Focus on subtle word choice and collocation accuracy, such as choosing more appropriate terms than 'background' when describing structural foundations.

GRA

Grammatical Range and Accuracy

7.0
Scoring rule

A variety of complex sentence structures, including conditional forms, are used effectively to present reasoned arguments.

Next step

Proofread carefully to eliminate minor errors in subject-verb agreement, noun pluralization, and correct article selection.

Put the feedback to work

Write this task while it is fresh

Try the same task now. It helps you remember the feedback and write better next time.

IELTS Writing Task 2

The best way to provide enough homes in large cities is to build tall apartment blocks. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?

Your response

Words0
40:00

Write the task yourself, then compare your choices with the annotated response.